American Catalog Mailers Association v. Director, Division of Taxation: State Taxation of Internet Based Activities
In American Catalog Mailers Association v. Director, Division of Taxation, the New Jersey Tax Court considered whether federal law preempts New Jersey regulations treating certain internet-based activities of out-of-state sellers as business activities conducted within New Jersey. The American Catalog Mailers Association (“ACMA”) is a trade association whose members include out-of-state internet sellers of tangible personal property, including home audio and video products. Its members also provide technical support through the internet and use internet cookies in connection with their websites.
Under Public Law 86-272, codified at 15 U.S.C. §§ 381-384, an out-of-state seller is protected from state net income taxation when its business activities within the state are limited to the solicitation of orders for tangible personal property and the statute’s other requirements are satisfied. ACMA argued that its members’ internet activities were analogous to activities historically performed by traveling salespersons, or “drummers,” and therefore remained protected under P.L. 86-272. ACMA asserted that P.L. 86-272 preempted the Director’s regulations. Both ACMA and the Division of Taxation moved for summary judgment.
Technical Support Issue
The court framed the issue as whether ACMA members engaged in “business activities within New Jersey” in addition to solicitation. The Director argued that interactive technical support constituted an in-state business activity because the customers receiving that support were located in New Jersey. ACMA countered that the activity occurred outside New Jersey because the sellers providing the support were located outside the State.
In analyzing the issue, the court drew a distinction between synchronous and asynchronous communications. The court analogized synchronous communication to an in-person or live remote class in which participants can ask questions and interact with an instructor. Asynchronous communication, by contrast, includes information prepared in advance and accessed later without real-time interaction.
Applying that distinction to internet activity, the court concluded that FAQs posted on a website are asynchronous. The information is created outside New Jersey and later accessed by a customer. Such activity does not constitute additional in-state business activity. Live electronic chats and internet help desks, however, are different because a seller is interacting with a customer located in New Jersey. The court determined that such interaction occurs both where the seller provides the support and where the customer receives it.
In reaching that conclusion, the court determined that P.L. 86-272 does not require a seller’s physical presence in New Jersey for the seller to conduct a business activity within the State. The court discussed the development of Commerce Clause jurisprudence, including South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., in addressing why modern internet activity cannot necessarily be attributed exclusively to the seller’s physical location.
Importantly, the decision does not establish a bright-line rule for every form of electronic communication. An email answered days later may resemble an asynchronous FAQ, while a near-real-time email exchange may more closely resemble interactive technical support. The court likewise declined to determine the treatment of AI-powered chatbots because the regulations and factual record did not adequately address that technology.
Cookies Issue
The Director’s regulations define an internet cookie as a small block of data created by a web server while a user browses a website and placed on the user’s computer or other device by the web browser. Under the regulations, whether a seller’s deployment of cookies constitutes an unprotected business activity depends upon how the cookies are used.
For example, cookies that facilitate the tracking of items in a buyer’s virtual shopping cart do not subject the seller to taxation because that activity constitutes part of the solicitation process. On the other hand, the regulations identify as an in-state business activity the use of cookies to gather and assemble market or product-research data for sale as customer or marketing information to data brokers or other third parties.
The court, however, identified a problem with the factual record. ACMA’s description of how its members actually used cookies was vague, and the parties did not present evidence establishing that ACMA members gathered and assembled customer data for sale in the manner described by the regulation. The court also recognized that common third-party analytics arrangements may operate differently, with third parties collecting data and providing analytical information back to sellers.
Accordingly, the court did not determine that ACMA members’ use of cookies constituted taxable New Jersey business activity. Rather, the court declined to adjudicate the validity of the cookie provision based upon a factual pattern that had not been established. The court further declined to rewrite the regulation to encompass different uses of cookies or third-party analytics and then determine whether those activities constituted in-state business activity.
Holding and Practical Significance
The court ultimately denied ACMA’s motion for summary judgment and granted the Director’s motion dismissing ACMA’s complaint. The decision, however, should not be understood as a categorical determination that all internet interactions by out-of-state sellers defeat P.L. 86-272 protection.
Rather, the decision indicates that the inquiry focuses on what the internet activity does and where that activity occurs. Interactive technical support provided to a New Jersey customer may constitute business activity within New Jersey even though the seller’s personnel remain outside the State. By contrast, passive or asynchronous activities may remain protected, and the decision leaves unresolved important questions concerning email communications, AI-supported customer service, and common third-party cookie and data-analytics arrangements.
For out-of-state sellers relying on P.L. 86-272, the decision provides an important reminder that the analysis should extend beyond the physical location of employees and property. Businesses should also examine how they interact electronically with New Jersey customers and whether those activities constitute solicitation or instead amount to separate business activities occurring within the State.